Do Nobodies Truely Die?

[Kaji no Kitsune]

~ getsumei ~

well, since nobodies don't even truely exist, their death would just mean that they ummm...dissapear visually?? confused i dunt think they're comming back though...

it just meen the remains of that soul is gone  

[Alixraen]

Ugh, its not Xenohart, its Xehanort. The name is also an anagram of "another" without the x.  

[Trigger Happy Xigbar]

i don't think they're dead. when you defeat them it looks like they're kind of leaving , not dying.  

[Medevilgirl]

Ok, I tried to read what every one has posted but, I'm lazy I only read half,

I don't think they're coming back, not in any form, ... well maybe,

But when they were defeated by Sora, they faded back into darkness, soul an all. They couldn't return to their hearts because their hearts were taken by darkness, and possibly stolen by a heartless.

Plus, by fading away into darkness, they would begin to forget everything, I figure this because that's what happened to Sora when he faded into darkness and became a heartless. He started to slowly forget everything, but then Kairi's voice brought him back.

If this is the case, then the members of organization XIII would not recall the world of light, would not remember they were missing a heart and would forget about who they were. Plus since their bodies disintegrated when they were beat, and if they could come back, there would be no body for them.

Nobody would see them. They would be even more of a nobody then before.

So in a way, it would be cruel to bring them back. I think having them fade away into a peaceful rest is better. A good ending for such great foes.

but that's just what I think 3nodding

 

[Annissina Fhang]

Organization 13 must return!!! because they are the awesomest bad guys ever. they must return, one form or another!!!  

[Jisen Meizuki]

Medevilgirl

Plus, by fading away into darkness, they would begin to forget everything, I figure this because that's what happened to Sora when he faded into darkness and became a heartless. He started to slowly forget everything, but then Kairi's voice brought him back.

If this is the case, then the members of organization XIII would not recall the world of light, would not remember they were missing a heart and would forget about who they were. Plus since their bodies disintegrated when they were beat, and if they could come back, there would be no body for them.

It is true that the Nobodies can't go back to their original bodies, but I don't think they would forget everything of who they are. I think you must be referring to Somebodies (aka Sora), not Nobodies. Somebodies would forget who they are when they became Heartless just like Sora did. But as for the Nobodies, I don't think they would forget who they were. For example, Roxas and Xemnas.

Roxas may not remember accurately about who he was before, but he did memories some of the events that Sora went through. Also, Roxas did went out to search for Sora before losing his memories again and ended up in Twilight Town.

Also, Xemnas does remember who he was before too. He remembers why he did the research, he remembers what happened to him and the others after the experiment failed, and he remembers who was his mentor is. Heck, he even remembers he used his mentor's name as his alias name.  

[Shinigami Kayako]

I hope they will return soon as well. We still don't know what happened to Ansem's Apprentices since we already know what happened to Xenohart. What about Xaldin, Xigbar, Vexen, Zexion, and Lexaeus' other half? Along with Axel and the others? We should know what happened to them, like in depth information.  

[Jisen Meizuki]

Ansem only had ONE apprentice, not six. The other five are followers and maybe co-workers of Xehanort, but they were not under Ansem's guidance.

EDIT:

My mistakes, Ansem does have six apprentices. However, those five follows Xehonart more than Ansem.  

[CiD the dark angel]

Medevilgirl

Ok, I tried to read what every one has posted but, I'm lazy I only read half,

I don't think they're coming back, not in any form, ... well maybe,

But when they were defeated by Sora, they faded back into darkness, soul an all. They couldn't return to their hearts because their hearts were taken by darkness, and possibly stolen by a heartless.

Plus, by fading away into darkness, they would begin to forget everything, I figure this because that's what happened to Sora when he faded into darkness and became a heartless. He started to slowly forget everything, but then Kairi's voice brought him back.

If this is the case, then the members of organization XIII would not recall the world of light, would not remember they were missing a heart and would forget about who they were. Plus since their bodies disintegrated when they were beat, and if they could come back, there would be no body for them.

Nobody would see them. They would be even more of a nobody then before.

So in a way, it would be cruel to bring them back. I think having them fade away into a peaceful rest is better. A good ending for such great foes.

but that's just what I think 3nodding

an interesting statement, but i disagree. Although they faded back into darkness, the fact that they had such strong wills is what made them Nobodys, so who says that they can't do it again? although i will agree that if their bodies were destroyed after being defeated, returning may not be possible. I suppose we'll just have to wait and see, won't we?  

[Medevilgirl]

I still think it would be cruel. crying

I mean what's the point for them to come back?

To continue existing as nothing.

unless, in kingdom hearts, they come up with some device that creates hearts for people, it wouldn't be unfair to bring them back.

Unless, depending on the character, they like being a nobody.  

[Jisen Meizuki]

Medevilgirl

Unless, depending on the character, they like being a nobody.

I don't think the Organization XIII like being Nobodies. Why do you think they built the Kingdom Hearts in the first place? Simple; because they want to be whole again.  

[CandlelightsChaos]

Hmm... By an overall conclusion from what's been said, I don't think that they're dead. I have this feeling that they'll come back or would in some sense either literal or figurative.  

[beehive130]

Ankoku_Ryuu

Jisen Meizuki

Xemnas is Xenohart's Nobody and Ansem is his Heartless

Really? I new that Xemnas was his Nobody, but Ansem being his heartless? Are ya talking about Ansem the Wise(who I ment), or the other dude? Speaking of, Why did they take on the name Ansem?

really its anagram of seman.  

[Happy Meal Toyfriend]

myaaa...That'd be beyond wonderful if they did come back...buuut...I dunno @_@  

[Auphon]

miss camella

What do you think about this question? Do you think that KH2 is the end of the organization? Do you truely think that there is no chance that they will not be coming back? Or do you think that they will be back in KH three? Any other speculations? Share them with us.

Well, it all depends on your definition of 'death' my friend. ^^