phantom of the opera (recent remake) or the count of monte c

[Celtic_RosePetal]

so i want to know which one is better phantom of the opera or the count of monte criso? i also would like ur opiions on both mives... smile  

[gOtHiC_MuSiC_DeVviL]

i saw the old one when i was really little and i liked a song in it..... and i think there was just too much singing!! it is a musical though but not my kinda thing. well Id have to watch it again lol. And I havent seen the 2nd one, ive seen it advertised and been wanting to watch it.  

[Midnight Phase]

I like both, the recent remake of Phantom of the Opera (if it's the one that was made in 2004) and The Count of Monte Cristo.

I love Phantom of the Opera because I love musicals, but it is really long. Though, I really do like The Count of Monte Cristo, it was a touching tale of revenge (that's how my film as lit. teacher put it anyways).  

[Laili]

The Phantom of the Opera actually stuck to the musical very closely. (I've seen it on Broadway).