2005
Decided By Rich Harden Oakland A
Edge [Leprechaun86]
Rhamm [Pharaoh Ramases]
Lita [Corollaresse]
Randy Orton [VivaLaRaza1994]
John Cena [???]

2007
Decided By J_B_Layfieldy
Kalos [iKal Enigma]
Bad Boy [WhosBadNowBoys1]
Drunko [Drunko]
Jed [JobsEveryDay]
Shawn Michaels [Rich Harden Oakland A]

2009
Decided By JobsEveryDay
Jarel Damone [Jarel Damone]
Sean Rowe
Slash and Axel
Matt Stone [Vandalium]
Jay Lighting [JayLightning]

2011
Decided by JobsEveryDay
Harli Drummond [Harli_Nightmare]
Draze [Draze666]
Team Prozac (Marxx and Shadow) [[M]a.r.t.s and Schevia]
The Outcasts (Nuke, Matt Shanahan and Christina Parks) [-Nuclear Fusion-, Punkology and o0 Mystique 0o]
Saint Joey [Extremist-Saint-Joey]

2013
Decided by Yukari Clepsydra
Nuke Fusion [-Nuclear Fusion-]
Matt Draven [Claire Hawkins]
Claire Hawkins [Claire Hawkins]
Midnight Marauders (Freakshow and Brantley Summers) [Scott Norton Fanclub and DankTectonics]

2014
Decided by Chrono Q Clepsydra
Cartwright [Cartwright]
Chrono Q Clepsydra [Chrono Q Clepsydra]
Mike Landry [Shining Mike]
Phoenixfire [Miss_Undastood]

2016:
[Approved by Miranda]
Decided by Chrono Q Clepsydra
Cyrus 'The Dream' Leone [Mister Mirage]
Tyson Biggs
Mystique [o0 Mystique 0o]
Mad Dogg
Aeron

2018
[Approved By Brad]
Decided by Chrono Q Clepsydra
Hiro [LoganComesAround]
Kid Omega [Kid_Omega91]
Brody Robinson [TechnicalPacifist]
Jacob Figgins [Braiddan]