Welcome to Gaia! ::

The Official How to Draw Manga Guild

Back to Guilds

 

Tags: artist, manga, anime, draw, learn 

Reply Main Guild Forum
Gaia Avatar Art: Critiques and Ratings, please!

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

*ACHOO*
  Bless you ouo
View Results

YayAuLait

Friendly Friend

PostPosted: Mon Jul 20, 2009 10:09 am


Hallo ouo~!

I'm going to open up an art shop soon with my friend, so I needed to draw some examples.. I'm going to work really hard on the orders I get, so I worked super hard on my example!

http://onehappystar.deviantart.com/art/Gaia-Online-Paradolic-130161059

Please rate it from 1-10 and critique please! Be very harsh/truthful, I don't mind. :> I'm more focused on the anatomy and coloring..~!

By the way, does anyone remember me? : D My username used to be HyperTomboy, but I changed it because I made that name when I was like... 10.. -u-.. Now I'm 13, I'm a man now. 8|..
PostPosted: Mon Jul 20, 2009 9:23 pm


Really cute, nice colouring, too.
Though, the legs and figures look.. a bit off, overall it's really cute. User Image I'd rate you a 8.5

winter rat


Amaya Himura X Zero Kiryu

PostPosted: Tue Jul 21, 2009 2:07 am


The chest is not queit right, you should try making it higher. But other than that your picture is pretty good! Others may say the legs and head are odd, but there are many types of styles to manga and you did a pretty good job! It took me a long time to figure out how to shape the legs, and at first the heads I drew were eithe to small, crooked, or to blocky. Not to mention the fact I couldn't draw feet until today.
PostPosted: Tue Jul 21, 2009 6:43 am


misfit baby
Really cute, nice colouring, too.
Though, the legs and figures look.. a bit off, overall it's really cute. User Image I'd rate you a 8.5


Thank you! ;u; such a high rating<3
The legs huh? I guess I'll look into it~ Thank you for the critique and compliments! :>

ssanimegirl
The chest is not queit right, you should try making it higher. But other than that your picture is pretty good! Others may say the legs and head are odd, but there are many types of styles to manga and you did a pretty good job! It took me a long time to figure out how to shape the legs, and at first the heads I drew were eithe to small, crooked, or to blocky. Not to mention the fact I couldn't draw feet until today.


Ahh.. I noticed it now since you mentioned it. Guess boobs don't go down there 8D;; OTLOTL
Thanks for the critique and the compliment~! Made me realize my mistake ;u;

Ohh ahah I see XDD Well... Practice make perfect! -u-<3

YayAuLait

Friendly Friend


abandoned_nr_5448214

Gambino Gaian

PostPosted: Tue Jul 21, 2009 11:56 am


Palms. The fingers are not supposed to be attached directly to the arm (sorry but you said harsh and I am a natural meanie). When you're sketching, make sure you draw out the palm area of the hand and make it no shorter than the fingers. Unless you are drawing some kind of half-chibi style (realistic chibi? dunno, I've just seen it sometimes) the hand should be long enough to cover the face. Try covering your face with your hand - you'll be amazed how big hands are!

Legs look rather good IMO. Could've been a bit wider, could've had a bit more flesh on them bones - but that's probably the fat girl inside me talking rolleyes Perhaps a bit more shape on those feet?

Your colouring are great, and those wings are fantastic! Her face is really pretty. Although the picture is a bit small I think I can hint details in the hair - lovely detail thinking there.
PostPosted: Tue Jul 21, 2009 5:40 pm


The_Witch_Aryllia
Palms. The fingers are not supposed to be attached directly to the arm (sorry but you said harsh and I am a natural meanie). When you're sketching, make sure you draw out the palm area of the hand and make it no shorter than the fingers. Unless you are drawing some kind of half-chibi style (realistic chibi? dunno, I've just seen it sometimes) the hand should be long enough to cover the face. Try covering your face with your hand - you'll be amazed how big hands are!

Legs look rather good IMO. Could've been a bit wider, could've had a bit more flesh on them bones - but that's probably the fat girl inside me talking rolleyes Perhaps a bit more shape on those feet?

Your colouring are great, and those wings are fantastic! Her face is really pretty. Although the picture is a bit small I think I can hint details in the hair - lovely detail thinking there.


Yes, I am happy you are harsh with your critique! ouo

I tried to draw palms/wrists noticably, I guess I didn't do so hot XD;;; Yess I know about the hands D; Hnnghh when I draw hands I make them small and try to make them BIGGER but it makes it look funky and I get unhappy cos I can't make the bigger yet PRETTY :CC

Okk I'll add some junk in the trunk next time XD LOL

Thank you for the critique and compliment! ;u;<33

Yess I draw my pictures are small scales XDDDD

YayAuLait

Friendly Friend


Vintrict

Omnipresent Poster

PostPosted: Tue Jul 21, 2009 5:50 pm


You at least got the coloring down. When it comes to drawing style, having some consistency in anatomy is needed, but you prove that coloring can still make a hell of a difference.

A 7 from me.
PostPosted: Tue Jul 21, 2009 6:08 pm


Vintrict
You at least got the coloring down. When it comes to drawing style, having some consistency in anatomy is needed, but you prove that coloring can still make a hell of a difference.

A 7 from me.


Thank you for the rate and comment ;U;<3333333

Aughh I need to work my coloring, too XD

YayAuLait

Friendly Friend


Count Chocolat

PostPosted: Wed Jul 22, 2009 2:47 am


I'd rate it somewhere around a 7.5

I really like the coloring, it's amazing.

But the legs look so skinny! I'm rather obsessing over that fact. Since girl legs are usually thicker than that, unless we're talking about a stick or an anorexic person. Plus, I like thicker legs. On guys too. I wonder if that's just me... Her left arm (our right) seems rather odd where the hand joins the arm... looks like there's no wrist, although her other hand looks PERFECT! ^^
Her chubby cheek is bothering me. Or maybe, it's just the way the hair covers the cheek in such a way that it looks chubbier...
PostPosted: Wed Jul 22, 2009 3:54 am


Count Chocolat
I'd rate it somewhere around a 7.5

I really like the coloring, it's amazing.

But the legs look so skinny! I'm rather obsessing over that fact. Since girl legs are usually thicker than that, unless we're talking about a stick or an anorexic person. Plus, I like thicker legs. On guys too. I wonder if that's just me... Her left arm (our right) seems rather odd where the hand joins the arm... looks like there's no wrist, although her other hand looks PERFECT! ^^
Her chubby cheek is bothering me. Or maybe, it's just the way the hair covers the cheek in such a way that it looks chubbier...


Thanks for the critique and compliments! ;u;

Yess I see many people are not too happy about her legs XDD I'll fix that next time I draw~ I like chubby legs too haha~

I like chubby cheeks ;u;<3 But if there is something to fix about her face, then I shall work on making my facial anatomy better XD

BTWWW I love Loveless!! That music video in your signature was amazing and adorable ;o;<33333333

YayAuLait

Friendly Friend

Reply
Main Guild Forum

 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum